Too Close

 

“I went out with Charles again last night,” Ashley begins. “You know the guy I met on Match who I’ve been out with a few times.”

“I remember,” I say, nodding at the computer screen. “You kind of liked him.”

“I guess, but he was a little too much last night.”

“Meaning?”

“I don’t know. Like he started telling me all about his childhood, which was pretty terrible. He was physically abused by his mother, like really bad. And he wanted to know all about me. I’m not sure I was ready for that.”

“What made you uncomfortable?”

“What if we don’t work out? Why should I tell him all about me? Does he really need to know that my mother died of cancer when I was four and that my father wanted nothing to do with me?”

“I’d say there would be no reason for him not to know.”

“I never understand why you feel I should be blabbing my whole life to anyone and everyone.”

“Well, if you’re not presenting who you are to people it’s kind of impossible to get close to them and it takes a lot of energy to be play acting through a large part of your life.”

“Aren’t you play acting? Isn’t being a therapist all play acting?”

“In what way?”

“You could be in terrible pain right now, physical or emotional, and you wouldn’t tell me about it, right?”

“That’s true. We do all have roles that we inhabit in our lives and…”

“See, I told you! So I’m no different than you or anyone else!”

“We all have roles that we inhabit. Being a therapist is one

role, just as being an attorney is another. And, no, in our professional roles we’re not telling everyone everything about us. You’re not going to be in front of a judge and say, “Your Honor I can’t try this case today because I had to put my dog down yesterday and I’m a total basket case. But yesterday, when you put your dog down – obviously I’m just using that as an example – would you have been able to call a friend and say I need to talk?”

“I don’t have a dog,” Ashley says matter-of-factly. “I don’t want a dog.” Pause. “Actually, dogs are kind of like that guy last night. They want too much. They’re always there, always begging. I guess you’ll say that’s my need to keep my distance.”

“Yes, I would. And there’s the question of why that distance feels so necessary for you.”

“It just popped in my head that we’re back in your office next week. I don’t like that idea either. This is much more convenient. I don’t have to drive to and from your office. I don’t have to waste time sitting in your waiting room. I just turn on my computer screen and here you are.”

“So I assume by bringing that up right now, you’re making the connection that returning to my office feels closer – literally and figuratively - than virtual therapy.”

“Right. And I’d prefer continuing just as we are.”

“So do you have any thoughts about what makes closeness so uncomfortable?”

“It’s messy. People are just so needy. They want so much. Just like a dog.”

“Are you needy, Ashley? Do you want so much?”

“Me? No way! I can take care of myself.”

“I think you learnt that early on. If there’s no one really there for you, you learn that you have to take care of yourself.”

“Right!”

“But there’s a problem with that, Ashley. When you were four years old you couldn’t take care of yourself. You were a helpless, dependent little girl who just lost the most important person in your life. That little girl is still inside you. She still wants and needs and longs for someone to care for her…”

“Ugh! That’s disgusting. I hope that’s not true. And if it is true I want her gone, poof! Like she never existed.”

“I wonder, Ashley, if that’s exactly the reason you didn’t like the man you saw last night and the reason you don’t want to return to in office visits and the reason you don’t want a dog, all of that brings you closer to that dependent, childhood part of yourself.”

“So what should I do about it?”

“Well, first we’ll resume in office visits and we’ll talk about how that feels for you. And when you’re with someone and feel the need to get away, maybe you can try to pay attention to what you’re really trying to get away from. I suspect it might be the needy part of yourself.”

“What if I just avoided people?”

“Well, what do you feel when you avoid people? What did you feel when we were locked down in the pandemic?”

“Lonely. Like something was missing.”

“I guess that’s your answer.”

I Have to See You

“I’m sitting in your parking lot,” Laurie says barely whispering into the telephone.

I consider asking her why, but I know the answer. Instead I say, “I’m sorry.”

“Not even your car is here. I thought maybe I’d at least see your car.”

“You know I’m working from home, Laurie.”

 “I know. But I thought maybe I’d get lucky.” Pause. “How long is this going to go on?” she asks, plaintively.  

“I don’t know. No one knows the answer to that.”

“But you could see me. We’re not under lockdown. I can eat in restaurants. I can have my hair done.”

“That’s all true, Laurie, but it doesn’t feel safe to me for us to be behind a closed door in a small space without a mask.”

“I know. I know. We’ve been through this a hundred times before. But I have to see you! I have to! I have to know you’re really here!”

“We did try FaceTime.”

“That’s worse. That’s like you’re here and not here. I don’t know. That totally spooked me. Then you really aren’t real. It’s almost like you’re a figment of my imagination. Like I willed you onto my phone. Flat. Way too flat.”

“Flat or dead?”

“I know you keep going back to that.” Pause. “Maybe. I don’t know. I went off to school, came home and my mother was dead. I’m sure that did a number on me. Oh yes, and by the way, she killed herself.”

“You’re talking about that horrible time almost like it happened to someone else.”

“I don’t want to feel that now! I’m too sad, way too sad, why would I want to start feeling about my mother offing herself?”

“Maybe because you are feeling it. Maybe because every time you pour over the statistics about how many people have died and how old they were and where they lived, you’re actually mourning your mother again and again.”

“Don’t I ever get to have mourned enough?”

“I think there are always times that losses in the present trigger past losses, especially when that loss was so primal.”

“How about if I met you in the parking lot for a session? At least that way I could see you.”

“And what? We’d both sit in our cars and …” I stop myself. Giving Laurie the practical reasons why her suggestion won’t work is not what’s needed here. “You know, Laurie, it strikes me that you’re trying to undo your mother’s death. It’s as though if you figure out a way to see me, to erase the missing, to erase the absence, then that will magically make everything all right including bringing your mother back to life.”

Silence.

“What do you feel if you accept that we’re not going to see each other for some indefinite period of time?” I ask.

“Angry!! Angry, angry, angry! Because it’s only an indefinite period of time because you’re making it an indefinite period of time. It’s you, you, you!! You’re doing this.”   

“Just like your mother killed herself.”

“Right! Who the fuck has the right to kill themselves and leave behind a six year old child? It’s not right! It’s not fair,” Laurie says sobbing.

“No, Laurie, it’s definitely not fair,” I say softly.

“Okay, so I’m mourning now, are you happy?”

“I’m definitely not happy you’re in pain, but you know I always think it’s best for you to feel whatever it is you’re feeling.”

“I want to see you! I want to see you! That’s what I’m feeling.”

“I’m sure that’s true. And I’m sure that’s what you were feeling as a child as well.”

“Fuck you! Leave me alone.”

Silence.

The silence continues.

I hear Laurie crying.

“I’m here Laurie,” I say quietly.

“You sure?” she whispers.

“I’m positive.”

“I used to make believe that I was talking to my mother on the phone, like she’d taken a trip somewhere and was missing me and couldn’t wait to get home to see me. Isn’t that pathetic?”

“No, Laurie, that’s not pathetic at all. It’s totally understandable and very, very sad. Don’t you feel for the little girl who was you who wanted her Mommy to come home?”

“I guess. Sometimes.” Pause. “And sometimes I just want her to stop being such a baby. I guess like I should stop being a baby when it comes to wanting to see you.”

“You’re not being a baby. You’re yearning for what your mother took away from you and what you feel I’m taking away from you too.”

“But you’re really here, right? I’m not just imagining you and I will get to see you again sometime?”

“Yes. I’m here. And we will see each other again.”

Removed

“I’m thinking of breaking up with the girl I’ve been dating,” Andrew begins. 

If I’m not mistaken, this is the third woman he’s broken up with in the several months I’ve been seeing him. Tall, with curly brown hair, 35 year old Andrew could be described as a handsome man, except that he feels too flat, too disengaged.  

“I know,” he continues, “I just said I thought she might be the one. I don’t know, we just don’t seem to click. I mean, we’re okay sexually, it’s not that. Maybe she’s too eager, too needy. I need her to back off. But that’s pretty crazy,” he says, half laughing at himself. “You’d think with my parents being so disconnected, I’d be dying to have a woman who’s really into me.”

“Can you say what she does that makes you feel she’s too needy and what goes on inside you?”

“I don’t know. Well, like she’s constantly texting me.” Pause. “But that’s not really true. She might text me in the morning and then once maybe after she’s done teaching for the day.”

“But it feels like a lot.”

“Yeah, that’s right. It feels like she’s always there.” 

“And when you’re actually with her?”

“I know this sounds bad, but I kind of want us to do whatever we’re going to do – go out to eat, go to the movies, whatever – go back to my place, have sex, and then have her leave. That’s enough for me.”

“While you’re with her, do you feel connected to her? You know, I just realized we’re both talking about ‘her,’ not using her name.”

“Her name’s Paula. And no, I don’t feel connected to her.” Pause. “I’m not sure I feel connected to anyone.”

“No one?”

“I don’t think so. I mean, I get along with people, I know what to say, how to act. But I wouldn’t say I feel connected. I tell my parents I love them. I hug my sister and my nieces. But it’s more that I know I’m supposed to do those things.” 

“Do you feel connected to me?”

“To you?” he asks, surprised.

I nod.

“No. We have a professional relationship. I pay you to listen to me and then I leave. I can’t imagine feeling connected to you.”

Kind of like what he wants from Paula, I think. What I say is, “Can you imagine feeling connected to anyone?”

“I guess my wife when I have one. And my kids, whenever that happens.”

“And not feeling connected, how does that make you feel?”

“I don’t know. Normal, I guess. Normal for me anyway. It’s how I’ve always felt.” 

“Do you ever feel lonely?”

“Lonely? I don’t know. I like being alone. I’ve always felt alone.”

“You know, Andrew, as I listen to you, I feel sad for you. You seem so alone, so cut off, so removed, both from others, as well as from your own feelings.”

He shrugs.

“And you did come into therapy. I think you said you wanted to figure out why you weren’t able to stay in a relationship with a woman. Sounds like we need to figure out why you can’t be in a relationship with anyone.”

“I guess.”

“Andrew, do you remember what you felt when you were little and your parents left you with one of your nannies and went away on business for months at a time.”

“That’s just how it was.”

“But how did you feel? How did you feel as that little boy?”

“I don’t remember.”

“Can you imagine doing that with your child some day?”

“Oh no! No, I couldn’t imagine ever doing that.”

“You seem to have more feelings about imagining leaving a child you still don’t have, leaving that imaginary child alone, than you’ve had about anything else we’ve talked about today.”

“I guess that’s true. But what does that mean?”

“That you’re that imaginary child; that buried deep inside you are lots of feelings about being left, sad feelings and scared feelings and angry feelings.”

“You think so?”

“Yes, I do.”

“So why don’t I feel them?”

“I imagine you locked those feelings away a long time ago and that opening that door feels overwhelmingly scary.”   

“And how’s that related to my not staying in relationships?”

“I think that when you start to get close to someone or if someone starts to get close to you, the possibility of needing or relying on that person brings you way too close to the scared, vulnerable, needy feelings you had as a child and you immediately close off and run away.”

“I guess that makes sense, but what do I do about it?”

“We start by carefully looking at your feelings as you go about relating to people in your life, including me, and seeing if we can find when you start to get scared and start pulling away.”

“Sounds like a long process.”

“I’m not planning on going anywhere.”

Panic

“I couldn’t wait to get here,” Ray says, almost breathless. “Pamela asked me for a divorce. She said we’ve been working on our relationship for years and it just doesn’t get any better. She wants out. She wants a chance to find greater happiness with someone else.”

“I’m sorry, Ray,” I say empathically.

“I…I’m a mess. I don’t think I’ve slept two hours since she told me. I never thought she’d leave me. I don’t know what to do. I can’t think straight. I’m like beyond panicked.”

“What’s fueling your panic?”

“What? What do you mean?”

“I can certainly understand you’re feeling sad and scared and maybe even angry, but what’s underneath your panic?”

“I’ll be alone. She’ll leave and take the kids and I’ll be alone. Oh my God, I can hardly say that. I can’t breathe.”

“I’m here. You’re not alone now. Take a few deep breaths and then let’s try to look at what feels so terrifying to you about being alone.”

Ray looks at me incredulously. He buries his head in his hands and tries to slow his breathing. He bursts into tears.

I sit silently while Ray cries, hoping he has broken through some of the anxiety to feel his sadness underneath.

“Why? Why? Why did she do this?”

Ray’s shock about his wife’s decision is rather surprising to me since they have indeed been working on their relationship for years. Ray told me she had repeatedly said she was unhappy in the relationship, feeling him unable to give to her emotionally or sexually.   

“What did prompt her decision?” I ask.

“I don’t know. Maybe because we didn’t have sex?” he says questioningly.

“You’ve told me that has been one of Pamela’s consistent complaints. That you withhold from her.”

“Do you break up a 15 year relationship because of sex?”

Ray’s consistent disbelief feels incredibly naïve to me. I even wonder if it’s disingenuous. Then I have another thought.

“You feel very much like a scared, hurt child to me,” I say gently.

Crying again, Ray mumbles, “That’s exactly how I feel.”

“So perhaps that’s why you’re panicked. When a child is left he feels panicked because he can’t survive without his mother - or some caretaker.”

“So you think Pamela’s leaving me feels like my mother leaving me?”

I nod.

“But my mother never left me.”

“That’s not exactly true Ray. You’ve told me how she reacted after your father died.”

“Yeah, that’s true. Before I was seven – when my father died – we had a very close relationship. In fact, she was all over me. Sometimes I just wanted to get away from her. It was too much. But after he died, I don’t know, it was like she died too. She got so depressed and didn’t want me anywhere around. In fact she shipped me off to her sister’s for a while. It was awful. My cousins hated me. I’m sure they didn’t want another kid in the family. I had to change schools and that was awful. The whole thing was awful.” Pause. “And when I went back home, my mother still rejected me.” Pause. “And then she started dating. That was worse. All those men. And then my step-father. The whole thing was a nightmare.” Pause. “You know what just went through my mind? I wanted my Mommy back.”

Crying, Ray adds, “And that’s how I feel right now. I want my Mommy. Except it’s Pamela.”   

I remain silent, thinking this is not the time to explore the meaning behind Ray’s similar feelings about his mother and Pamela.

“I guess that helps explain my panic,” he continues. “But it doesn’t take it away,” he adds, looking at me beseechingly. “Can’t you take it away?”

“So perhaps now I’m the Mommy who you want to take away all your fears and sadness.”

“Can you?”

“That’s clearly your wish, but I’m afraid I have no magic wand.”

“No?”

“No, but we can look at your desire for that magic wand, for the all-powerful, all-perfect mother who can take away all your fears, all your sadness so that you feel nothing but perpetual bliss.”

“Sounds wonderful.”

“But I wonder if it would feel wonderful or, as you said before about your early mother, whether it would feel too much and you’d want to get away.”

“I don’t know. Right now it sounds wonderful.”

“When faced with abandonment you yearn for closeness, but when there’s closeness it can feel like too much and you yearn to get away.”

“I don’t know. I can’t deal with all that now.”

“I understand. We’ll have plenty of time.”

Misery

Beth smiles wanly at me as I open the waiting room door. I anticipate a long, dreary session.

“I’m still miserable,” she says, sitting down, immediately confirming my worst fears. I do understand that Beth has good reason to be miserable. Her husband divorced her after 20 years of marriage, leaving her with two teenagers, three dogs and a six bedroom house. It’s a lot to deal with. And we’ve been dealing with her misery for almost two years.

“Of course I had another problem this week. The kitchen sink started leaking. I freaked out. I went running around to my neighbors to ask if they knew a plumber. Luckily one of them did.”

Knowing I am about to make a futile statement, I say, “So that’s something that worked out well.”

“Not really. It took me days to reach the plumber and then more days before he could come. And in the meantime the kids and I had to eat out which certainly doesn’t help my budget.” She sighs. “It’s all so complicated. I don’t know why life has to be so difficult.”

I wonder how many times I have said things such as, ‘life can be difficult and you’ve certainly had a difficult time, but life can bring lots of joy as well.’  I remain silent.

“Well …?” she says.

My stomach tightens. I feel as though she is commanding me to respond.

“What is it that you want from me right now?” I ask. I hear my choice of words, the tone of my voice and realize that Beth is making me feel as she feels – burdened, put upon, ineffectual, despairing. Ineffectual. That’s an interesting word to flit through my mind. Perhaps that’s what Beth feels. Now alone, she feels unable to competently contend with life.

“I need you to reassure me, to tell me that it will all work out okay.”

“Would you believe me?”

Beth opens her mouth to speak and then stops. After a pause she says, “Well if you said it, it might reassure me.”   

This time I don’t hear Beth’s words as a command to speak, but rather a wish that I take care of her. “I understand that you want reassurance, but you often hear that reassurance as empty words.”

“But I don’t know what to do. I have all these responsibilities. The kids. They’re certainly becoming more than a handful. How am I supposed to handle two teenagers by myself?” She takes a breath. “And what if I get sick? That’s all I’d need. How could I take care of all the things I need to take care of if I got sick? Who would take care of me?”

“I definitely hear how overwhelmed you feel, Beth. Like there are all these things that happen on a day to day basis and then there are all the things that might happen. How are you going to cope?”

“Exactly.”

“But I wonder, Beth, if it would be more helpful to you if you were able to see your own strength, if you were able to realize that you’re far more capable than you think you are.”

“But I’m not!”

“Do you really feel as though you’re not a competent, capable adult or are you afraid to let yourself know you’re a competent, capable adult?”

“They always said I wasn’t.”

“Who’s they?”

“My parents, my sisters, my husband. Even my children. They say I’m a wreck, that I can’t do anything right, that I’m always running around in circles. And I am. I’ve been doing that my whole life.”

“So what would it feel like to be competent?”

“How do I know? I’ve never felt it.”

“Would you like to?”

“Of course!”

“Beth, can you think about that a bit more? I wonder two things: If feeling competent feels so foreign to you that it would be like you’re becoming another person and that in itself would feel pretty scary. And two, you’re not sure you want to be all grown up before you find someone who’ll take care of you.”

“My husband said he’d take care of me. But he never did. He just nagged at me for what I didn’t do right. Even my parents. I was the fifth girl. They’d had enough by that time. I was kind of an add-on.”

“I understand, Beth, that it’s very difficult to give up on wanting the love and caretaking you never had, but there’s no way to get that kind of caretaking as an adult. It doesn’t mean you can’t be loved and cherished, but you can’t go back to being the child and, in the end, it does feel much better to have confidence in your ability to take care of your adult self.”